Every fitness app compared, fairly

We paid for six fitness apps and trained with each for weeks, not minutes. Here is the ranking, the real dollar price, and who each one actually fits.

See the full ranking
10scoring criteria
6apps we paid for
21+days on each one
0paid placements

How the scores are built

We do not grade an app from its store listing. Each one is scored on the same set of criteria after weeks of real training, and the average sets its place in the table.

Coaching and programming

Weight: high

Does the app actually direct your training, with a plan that progresses, or does it just hand you a pile of videos to sort through yourself?

Value for the U.S. price

Weight: high

We convert every plan to a real dollar figure, monthly and annual, and weigh it against what you get after the free week ends.

Phone experience mid-set

Weight: medium

Run one real session with sweat on the screen. The rest timer, the cues and the next-exercise tap have to stay out of your way.

Equipment assumptions

Weight: medium

We note exactly what gear each program takes for granted, from a bare mat in a studio apartment to a full rack in a home gym.

Cancellation and billing

Weight: medium

How easy is it to leave? We cancel every subscription ourselves and record whether it took two taps or an email chase.

Guides from the desk

Short, practical reads for anyone weighing up an app. We refresh these alongside the ranking.

How to choose a fitness app

Five checks worth running before your card gets charged, from coaching style to the renewal price.

Read the guide

Training at home with no kit

What a mat and twenty minutes genuinely gets you, and where a pair of dumbbells starts to matter.

Read the guide

Coached app or a real trainer

Where a $30 app is plenty, and where paying a human who watches your form earns its keep.

Read the guide
All guides

The ranking of fitness apps

This order reflects how consistently each app kept a U.S. subscriber training month after month. The name opens the full review; the button opens the official site, where the current price always takes priority.

Future Top 2025 ★★★★½4.8

One human coach who writes your plan and texts you through the week. Around $199/mo, and the app that earned the most loyalty in our test.

Join Future
#AppRatingPriceBest forWhat stands out
2 FitOn ★★★★½4.7 Free / $29.99 a year (Pro) All levels A genuinely free library of on-demand and live classes across many styles Join
3 Centr ★★★★½4.5 $29.99/mo Beginner to advanced Workouts, meal plans and meditation bundled into one guided subscription Join
4 Tonal ★★★★☆4.4 $59.95/mo + hardware All levels A wall-mounted smart gym with digital resistance and coached strength sessions Join
5 Freeletics ★★★★☆4.3 $34.99/quarter Intermediate An adaptive coach that builds bodyweight and strength plans around your feedback Join
6 Peloton ★★★★☆4.2 $12.99/mo (app) All levels Studio-style cycling, running and strength classes led by named instructors Join

The editor's pick

One app stood out across the test for keeping a subscriber engaged past the first burst of motivation.

Future logo
Best overall

Future ★★★★½4.8

  • A real coach writes the plan, watches your logged sessions, and messages you through the week
  • The program is not fixed: ours swapped exercises we kept avoiding for ones we would stick with
  • That weekly back-and-forth is the whole product, and it changes how answerable the week feels

Future earns the top spot for anyone who genuinely wants accountability and would otherwise book a personal trainer. The catch is the price: at $199 a month it only pencils out against hiring a human, not against a $30 app. If you are self-directed, FitOn or Centr cover most of the ground for far less.

Join Future

Common questions

Some of the outbound links to apps are affiliate links. If you subscribe through one, the company pays us a commission at no extra cost to you. That money never buys a higher spot: the scores come from the editors after testing.
We go through prices and program changes every couple of months, and again whenever a company announces a change. The last review date sits in the byline under each review.
If you have never followed a structured plan, Centr eases you in with short guided sessions and a patient tone. FitOn is a strong free starting point too. Future is excellent but built for someone who wants a coach, not a first week.
We only include apps that work from the United States and run a real program you can follow. A bare exercise library with no structure belongs in a different comparison.
We do not publish user-submitted stars, because we cannot verify them. Every number comes from our own paid testing, and we show how we reached it in the scoring section of each review.
No. We pay for every subscription so the experience matches yours. If a company offered free access for coverage, we would note it in the review and keep paying anyway.
It depends on the app. Each review lists what gear the programs assume. FitOn and Freeletics lean bodyweight; Tonal needs its hardware; the coached apps work best with at least some weights.
Please do. Email us at info@backoemovementis.world. If it runs a real program and is available from the United States, we will add it to the testing queue.

Ready to pick your app?

Put all six side by side and find the one that fits how you actually train.

Open the full ranking